1957 Martin D-28: The Golden Age Brazilian Beauty

Why the 1957 D-28 Represents the Pinnacle of American Guitar Craftsmanship

The 1957 Martin D-28 stands as one of the finest examples of American acoustic guitar manufacturing at its absolute peak. Built during the height of the 1950s boom when Martin guitars were so sought-after that customers often waited two years or more for delivery, these instruments represent a perfect convergence of premium materials, refined craftsmanship, and tonal excellence that has never quite been matched.

What makes 1957 particularly special is its position in the timeline of acoustic guitar evolution. Martin had perfected their construction techniques after decades of refinement, yet still had access to the extraordinary Brazilian rosewood and premium spruce that would become increasingly scarce in later decades. These guitars command premium prices today, with excellent condition examples ranging from $9,000 to $12,000, reflecting their status as some of the most coveted vintage acoustic guitars ever produced.

The 1957 D-28 embodies everything that made the 1950s the golden era of American guitar manufacturing: old-growth tonewoods, hand-selected materials, and construction methods that prioritized tone and resonance over efficiency.

Historical Context: Martin at Its Creative Peak

By 1957, C.F. Martin & Company had been building guitars for over a century, and the D-28 model itself had been in production for 26 years. The company had weathered the Great Depression, World War II material shortages, and emerged stronger than ever in the post-war boom. The 1950s represented Martin's golden age—demand was so high that customers regularly faced waiting lists of two years or more.

In 1957, Martin was using a mix of premium top woods including Sitka spruce, red spruce (often called Adirondack), and German spruce, depending on availability and specific orders. This variety in top woods makes each 1957 D-28 unique in its tonal characteristics, as different spruce types contribute distinct sound qualities.

The year 1957 also marked a significant period in American music history. Folk music was experiencing a renaissance, bluegrass was establishing itself as a distinct genre, and country music was evolving rapidly. The D-28's powerful projection and rich harmonics made it the perfect instrument for this musical revolution. Artists like Hank Williams had already demonstrated the D-28's capabilities, and the folk revival of the late 1950s and early 1960s would cement its legendary status.

During this period, Martin's attention to detail was legendary. Each guitar was essentially handmade, with premium materials hand-selected for tonal qualities. The company's reputation for excellence was at its absolute peak, making 1957 D-28s coveted both as musical instruments and as representatives of American craftsmanship.

Current Market Value (2025 Update)

The 1957 Martin D-28 has shown remarkable appreciation over the past decade, with values steadily climbing as collectors and players recognize the exceptional quality of this golden era production.

Key Value Factors:

• Originality: All-original examples command significant premiums. Collectors specifically seek instruments that are "all original, crack free" and don't need neck resets

• Condition: Clean examples with minimal playing wear bring top dollar

• Top Wood Type: Red spruce (Adirondack) tops are particularly prized and can add 10-15% to value

• Documentation: Original case, receipts, or provenance add significant value

• Neck Reset History: Guitars requiring neck resets trade at discounts of $1,000-$2,000

• 
  

Important Note: At Edgewater Guitars, we consistently pay 30-40% more than typical guitar shops for premium vintage Martin instruments, recognizing their true market value and investment potential.

Detailed Identification Guide

Serial Number Ranges

1957 Martin guitars fall within the serial number range of 153,226 to 159,061. The serial number is located inside the guitar body, visible through the soundhole on the neck block. You may need a flashlight to read it clearly.

Serial Number Location: The serial number is stamped on the neck block inside the guitar, typically visible when looking through the soundhole toward the neck joint.

Martin Factory Records

Martin kept detailed production records, including the type of spruce used for each guitar's top. These records can often identify whether your 1957 D-28 has a Sitka, red spruce, or German spruce top, which affects both tonal characteristics and collector value.

Wood Identification Features

Brazilian Rosewood Back and Sides:

• Rich chocolate to deep purple-brown coloration

• Distinctive grain patterns with dramatic figuring

• Dense, heavy feel compared to later Indian rosewood

• Often shows beautiful "flame" or "ribbon" patterns in the grain

Top Wood Variations:

• Sitka Spruce: Even, straight grain with cream to light amber coloration

• Red Spruce (Adirondack): Tighter grain patterns, often with slight yellow cast

• German Spruce: Very straight, even grain with bright white appearance

Hardware and Appointments

Original 1957 Features:

• Kluson "waffle-back" sealed tuning machines with white plastic buttons

• Ebony fingerboard with simple dot position markers

• Ebony bridge with through-saddle design

• Tortoise celluloid pickguard

• White plastic binding around body

• Natural finish with subtle aging

Construction Details:

• Dovetail neck joint (14-fret neck)

• Brazilian rosewood back and sides, mahogany neck

• Traditional X-bracing pattern

• Bone nut and saddle

• Original frets were typically lower and narrower than modern standards

Detailed Physical Specifications

Body Dimensions:

• Length: 20 inches

• Lower Bout Width: 15⅝ inches

• Upper Bout Width: 11½ inches

• Body Depth: 4⅞ inches

Neck Specifications:

• Nut Width: 1⅝ inches (typical for era)

• Neck Profile: Soft V to C-shape, comfortable for most players

• Scale Length: 25.4 inches (standard Martin scale)

• Fretboard Radius: Approximately 16-inch radius

Weight and Feel:

• Typical weight around 4.4 pounds, though this can vary

• Balanced feel with excellent upper fret access

• Substantial but not overly heavy construction

Electronics:

• No original electronics (acoustic only)

• Pure acoustic design optimized for natural projection and resonance

Case:

• Originally shipped with brown hardshell case with pink or maroon plush interior

• Original cases add significant value and authenticity to the package

Tonal Characteristics

The 1957 Martin D-28 delivers the quintessential dreadnought sound that became the blueprint for countless other manufacturers. The combination of Brazilian rosewood and premium spruce creates a tonal complexity that has made these guitars legendary among players and recording engineers.

Sound Profile:

• Bass Response: Deep, powerful fundamentals with rich overtones from the Brazilian rosewood

• Midrange: Warm, woody character that cuts through mix without harshness

• Treble: Crisp, clear highs with excellent note separation and sustain

• Projection: Exceptional volume and presence, perfect for rhythm work or fingerpicking

Why the Tone is Special: These guitars are described as "very open, responsive, and loud" with characteristics that would "make most any flatpicker quite pleased". The Brazilian rosewood contributes a complex harmonic structure that Indian rosewood simply cannot match, while the premium spruce tops provide clarity and projection.

Comparison to Modern Instruments: The aged tonewoods in a 1957 D-28 have had nearly 70 years to mature and open up. This aging process creates a richness and complexity of tone that new instruments cannot duplicate. The hand-selected materials and traditional construction methods result in superior resonance and sustain.

Recording and Performance: These guitars excel in both studio and live settings. The powerful projection makes them ideal for acoustic performances, while the balanced frequency response translates beautifully in recordings. Many classic country, folk, and bluegrass recordings feature the distinctive sound of 1950s Martin dreadnoughts.

Common Issues & Modifications

When evaluating a 1957 Martin D-28, be aware of typical age-related issues and common modifications that affect both playability and value.

Typical Problems:

• Neck Reset Needs: Most 1950s Martin dreadnoughts need neck resets if they've been strung with medium gauge strings throughout their life

• Bridge Issues: Original bridges may show wear, cracks, or may have been replaced

• Pickguard Shrinkage: Celluloid pickguards often shrink and curl with age

• Finish Checking: Natural aging of nitrocellulose finish creates fine crack patterns

• Binding Separation: Age can cause binding to separate, particularly at body curves

Common Modifications to Watch For:

• Replaced Tuners: Many have been upgraded to modern sealed tuners

• Refrets: Most will have been refretted at least once due to normal wear

• Bridge Work: Saddle modifications or complete bridge replacements

• Electronics Additions: Some have had pickups installed

• Neck Angle Changes: Previous neck resets or repairs

Red Flags for Authenticity:

• Refinishing: Complete refinishes significantly impact value, though some light oversprays may be acceptable

• Incorrect Hardware: Non-period tuners, bridges, or other appointments

• Structural Repairs: Major crack repairs, especially on the top

• Serial Number Issues: Altered, missing, or suspicious serial numbers

Evaluation Tips:

• Check for the "straightedge test" - a ruler laid on the fretboard should clear the bridge top

• Examine the finish for authenticity and age-appropriate checking

• Verify all hardware matches period specifications

• Look for tool marks or other signs of amateur repairs

Why Players and Collectors Value the 1957 D-28

The 1957 Martin D-28 represents a perfect storm of factors that created an instrument of exceptional quality and enduring desirability.

Playing Characteristics:

• Comfort: The 1950s neck profile suits most playing styles without being overly thick

• Responsiveness: These guitars are noted for being "very open, responsive, and loud"

• Versatility: Equally at home with flatpicking, fingerpicking, or strumming

• Projection: Exceptional volume without sacrificing tonal complexity

Collector Appeal:

• Material Rarity: Brazilian rosewood is no longer available for new instruments

• Historical Significance: Represents the peak of 1950s American guitar manufacturing

• Build Quality: Hand-selected materials and traditional construction methods

• Investment Potential: Steady appreciation over decades with strong market demand

Musical Heritage: The 1957 D-28 was built during a crucial period in American music history. The folk revival, the emergence of bluegrass as a distinct genre, and the evolution of country music all relied heavily on the sound of Martin dreadnoughts. Owning a 1957 D-28 connects you directly to this musical heritage.

Investment Considerations: Market discussions suggest these guitars have shown steady appreciation, with premium examples becoming increasingly scarce. The combination of exceptional playability and investment potential makes them attractive to both serious players and collectors.

Selling Your 1957 Martin D-28

If you own a 1957 Martin D-28, you possess one of the most sought-after vintage acoustic guitars in the world. At Edgewater Guitars, we specialize in providing fair market valuations for these exceptional instruments.

Why Choose Edgewater Guitars:

• Premium Valuations: We consistently pay 30-40% more than typical guitar shops

• Expert Authentication: Our team can verify originality and assess condition factors

• Immediate Payment: No consignment fees or lengthy waiting periods

• Specialized Knowledge: We understand the nuances that affect 1957 D-28 values

• Discretion and Security: Professional handling of high-value instruments

Our Evaluation Process:

1. Initial Assessment: Free consultation to discuss your guitar's condition and history

2. Professional Inspection: Detailed examination of all authenticity and condition factors

3. Market Analysis: Current pricing research based on recent sales and market trends

4. Immediate Offer: Fair cash offer based on true market value

5. Secure Transaction: Professional documentation and immediate payment

What Sets Us Apart: Unlike general music stores that may not recognize the full value of a 1957 D-28, Edgewater Guitars specializes in vintage instruments. We understand factors like top wood types, originality premiums, and condition nuances that significantly affect value.

Get Your Free Valuation: Ready to discover what your 1957 Martin D-28 is worth? Contact Edgewater Guitars today for your free, no-obligation valuation. Call us directly at (440) 219-3607 or fill out our online quote form.

Related Resources

Authentication and Dating:

• Martin Guitar Serial Number Lookup Tool

• Complete Martin Dating Guide by Decade

• Brazilian Rosewood Identification Guide

• How to Spot Refinished Martin Guitars

Selling and Valuation Resources:

• Sell Your Martin Guitar - Edgewater Guitars

• Vintage Guitar Market Trends 2025

• Martin D-28 Value Factors Checklist

• Professional Guitar Appraisal Services

Related Vintage Martin Models:

• 1956 Martin D-28: Pre-'57 Characteristics

• 1958 Martin D-28: Post-'57 Changes

• 1957 Martin D-18: The More Affordable Alternative

• 1957 Martin 000-28: Concert Body Alternative

Recent Purchase Example

Cleveland Collector Success Story:

We recently had the privilege of purchasing a 1957 Martin D-28 from a longtime collector in Cleveland, Ohio. The guitar, serial number 156,234, was an all-original example in excellent condition with its original brown hardshell case and even the original sales receipt from 1957.

The owner had inherited the guitar from his father, who purchased it new in Cleveland in 1957. After decades of careful storage, the guitar retained its original finish, hardware, and even the original frets. Our expert evaluation confirmed the guitar's authenticity and exceptional condition.

The Edgewater Advantage: Our offer exceeded the owner's expectations by more than $3,000 compared to quotes from local music stores. Within 48 hours of initial contact, we had completed the evaluation, made our offer, and finalized the transaction with immediate payment.

"I couldn't believe how much more Edgewater offered compared to the music stores I contacted," the seller noted. "Their knowledge of vintage Martin guitars was immediately apparent, and they understood details that other buyers missed entirely."

This transaction exemplifies our commitment to recognizing the true value of exceptional vintage instruments and providing sellers with fair, immediate compensation.

Expert Authentication and Market Leadership

As Ohio's premier vintage guitar buyers, Edgewater Guitars has built a reputation for expertise in identifying and valuing exceptional instruments like the 1957 Martin D-28. Our team combines decades of experience with current market knowledge to ensure accurate valuations and authentic transactions.

Our Service Area: Edgewater Guitars serves vintage guitar owners throughout Ohio, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Indiana, and West Virginia. For high-value instruments like 1957 D-28s, we provide in-person evaluations to ensure accurate assessment and secure transactions.

Contact Edgewater Guitars Today: Don't let your 1957 Martin D-28 sit unplayed or undervalued. Contact Edgewater Guitars for your free consultation and discover why we're the Midwest's trusted choice for vintage guitar sales.

Phone: (440) 219-3607
Service Area: Ohio, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Indiana, West Virginia
Specialization: Premium vintage guitars, Martin authenticity, fair market valuations

Edgewater Guitars - Where vintage guitar expertise meets fair market value.